Right now I am really liking the deep wine and berry colors but if that's too much for you go with a more neutral tone. Although why not step out of the box and try something new?!
I used MAC: Half-Red lip pencil - Line around edges and bring it in from the corners just a bit to give dimension and Viva Glam IV lipstick - It's a frost finish so that is what gives it that shine.
Be sure to use a lip pencil so the lipstick wont bleed.
Good luck and let me know how it goes!